The episode begins with Meatwad and Master Shake at curve on the highway. Shake throws a water balloon on the road, but it does nothing, it just splats on the ground. Then, he has a large piece of concrete and explains to Meatwad that he gonna do a diversion to streak through town even though he nor Meatwad don't even wear any clothing, he pushed it over the highway, eventually, car crashes, blood, screams, and explosions heard in the background as the two both watch in horror, Shake does his plan, but was stopped by an angel. and it reveals that he is one of many people that was killed which Master Shake has cause in that devastation. Meatwad don't know who the angel is and the angel allows Meatwad to go, Shake inadvertently shoves him off the road, only to do the same exact thing from earlier.
The angel says he got plans for Master Shake, so he teleports Shake and himself to the Hospital. Both see a dead man on a bed and the angel demanded Shake to read him a story, he refuses thus sticking up his middle finger at him. Angered, the angel summons Shake into hell by engulfing him into flames, he comes back and promise to read a pop up book called "Sammy the Gerbil and his Muffin Adventure, Shake points out there is no pages and says nobody would visit the old man due to him dying, the angel does the same thing again. Shake finally reads it, but the angel says to reading the same title. Later, he use a water filter to clean Carl's pool, Shake gets angry with him, but the angel says they can go back to that "awful place", Shake was shock and apologizes to him. Carl comes out, as Shake speaking with the angel due to him being the only one to see him, Shake says to Carl that the angel is his agent. Then, he points out to Carl that he talking to a fucking angel, then the angel makes him say he that that he changed his ways and asks Carl what he wants. Carl wants a half-dozen black graphic-tees with wings and the barbed wire that says "Choke Out". When he bought him the shirts, it says "Surfs Up", with whales, to much of Carl agony. He buys Carl the right shirts, much for his delight. The angel demands Shake to thank him, he refuses, only to go back into hell, too much of Carl shockness. He thanks him and reveals to use his over-extended credit cards. Then Carl make Shake to washed 2 Wycked, which he does. He ask the angel why he doing this to him, because he killed him, then threaten to uses a piece of concrete to smash his head opened, Shake was horrified to hear that. The angel says he has diarrhea and he leaves, which gives Shake to call on Frylock for help.
He types on Frylock computer in his room to see how to get rid of the angel, Frylock wants to know what he doing, Shake scolds him. The angel finds him, he still has diarrhea and has to leave again because the Aqua Teens do not have a bathroom at their house. Frylock tries to help Shake, but he destroys his computer. Shake meets with a juggalo fan named Neilzabub, he ask Neilzabub if he bring references, which is only a spider. At Foodie Mart, Master Shake appears as a juggalo, the angel also appears, Shake asks for Neil help, so Neil and his two friends drink beer that Shake purchases for them, then he read some lyrics from the back of an Insane Clown Posse T-Shirt. It does nothing to the angel, Neil says he doing it wrong, and ask if he and the angel drives them to an ICP concert, Shake asks if his mom picking him up, but saying one of Neil friends sneaking out, then turns into an argument. Shake is furious at Neil for not telling his mom, the angel get mad and sends Master Shake to the "awful place" three times, which amazes Neilzabub and his friends, Neil ask the if he can show how he do it, the angel ask what age is Neil, Neil responds that he 14 1/2 years old. An infuriated Shake comes back to tell Neil and his goons that they was fully licensed, but Neil says his father is an attorney. Pissed off because all of the harsh things that he done throughout the entire episode, Shake says goodbye to everyone as he grabs a shotgun, place it in his mouth, and blast his head off, thus killing him in the process as his remains come back to land on the ground. At a courthouse, George Lowe fills in as Frylock lawyer, as he and a very sad Meatwad, who in tears because of Shake death and holding a picture of him. It reveals that Frylock sue the ICP, Shaggy 2 Dope and Violent J because of their insane lyrics that drives to Shake committing suicide. George ask how offensive is that, only leading to Frylock angrily clearing his throat as Shake death, George change his mind and explains to the courtroom that their songs drive Shake to die. The ICP interjects and saying that their is multiple ICP in the area, like singing to dead people. They also breathe fire, and they burn the courthouse down with Lowe saying "No further questions." Credits. As the credits roll, Shake is shown to be in hell washing Carl's car, the angel appears again, like he said earlier, he shove a piece of concrete at Shake head, killing him again.
- An unnamed person is killed in a car crash caused by Master Shake.
- Master Shake kills himself with a shotgun.
- ICP burns down the courthouse, killing Frylock, Meatwad, George Lowe and several unnamed people.
- Master Shake has a slab of concrete hit his head while in Hell.
- Neil-zebub makes a cameo appearance in "Totem Pole."
- This is one of the many episodes Shake has died.
- Meatwad and Carl are the only characters that don't know the angel.
- Carl is the only main character to survive this episode.